Historic Zoning Commission June 17, 2026 · Wednesday, June 17, 2026 · 1h 20m

The one where the neighbors who WROTE the historic overlays showed up to enforce them against the additions their own ru

Contents & search

Try

A Metro Historic Zoning Commission docket of rear additions, rooftop bump-ups and an outbuilding turned into a philosophical fight over what 'preservation' means. Case after case tested the same guideline, an addition should not more than double a house's footprint, nor grow wider or both taller-and-wider than the original. The residents pushing hardest weren't outsiders: Elizabeth Roseman said she was instrumental in creating the Richland West End overlay, and Ron Emerson invoked the rare 1908 Sears Roebuck mail-order kit house across the street. The commission split, approving most projects

From the room

“The preservation permit is not a building permit. No work can begin without the appropriate review”
— Melissa

“No major Planning Commission report. I'm try figure out how we can get in on this data center business”
— Planning Commission representative (Lee Rollin Woody / SPEAKER_05)

“Staff finds that the addition meets all design guidelines and finds that the proposed addition does not overwhelm”
— Joseph

“smaller and subservient to the the historic house in in addition to despite, public comment to the contrary.”
— Commissioner (SPEAKER_10)

Also in the record

Records not linked to a specific agenda item

Conditions

the hip wing of the rooftop addition does not extend taller than the side gabled ridge
require applicant to bring back an alternative compliant design before the commission in public with full community notice before any approval finalized or permit issued
need to see revised drawings and a recommendation before commission can make the decision; cannot decide in this meeting without them
roof form must be lower than the side gable; hipped or other roof form acceptable if lower than side gable
the application includes an outbuilding that staff recommends for approval; could be separated and approved independently of the addition
Staff recommends approval of proposed addition and outbuilding with standard conditions plus a non-standard condition (number two)

+5 more conditions

Questions & answers

Jamie Sims: what are our next steps / seeking commission guidance on the rear-addition-guideline proposal

SPEAKER_03: If the applicant needs to see drawing changes before approval, does this need to be disapproved or does the applicant need to withdraw?

SPEAKER_05: Could we move to approve the staff recommendation with a further condition that revised roof plans be seen by the chair or executive committee?

SPEAKER_05: Jenny, what's the deadline for next month's submittal?

Commissioner Gadd: For condition two, does that include siding?

+2 more exchanges

Citations & precedent

preservation permit vs building permit · Melissa

writ of certiorari appeal rights · Melissa

appeal filing deadline · Melissa

section six subsection b number seven of the guidelines · Elizabeth Roseman

section six subsection b number seven · Elizabeth Roseman

Secretary of Interior guidelines · Martha Emerson

Woodland and Waverly overlay guideline: no matter its use, an addition should not be larger than the existing house · Elizabeth Williams

Procedure

up to twenty minutes total, two minutes per speaker, limited to non-public-hearing agenda items — Chair
limited to agenda items for which a public hearing will not be held — Chair
tentative consent item pulled at public request — Melissa
chair agrees to hold a public hearing and present the project — Chair

+4 more procedural steps

The people

Public testimony: 1 opposed

Practitioners & applicants

Ron Emerson · Martha Emerson · Martin Wick · Anthony Monica · Lee Rollin Woody

The intelligence

Every parcel, owner, and applicant in this meeting, cross-referenced against Zonable’s NYC ownership, enforcement & legislative graph — the record behind the record.

Sign in for the full graph

Owner portfolios, open OATH/ECB violations, 311 & DOB permits across every parcel discussed, developer track records, and an “ask this meeting” chat.

Ask about this meeting

Chat with AI about this meeting. Free account required.