Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises · Thursday, January 9, 2025
The one where Park Slope's Arrow Linen fight swallowed a whole hearing while the city's $100M life-science campus sailed
Contents & search
items
7
laid over
7
land-use items
7
units
331
affordable
378
avg AMI
66%
Try
Two visions of NYC development collided in one zoning subcommittee. First, the city's own SPARC Kips Bay and Taconic life-science campuses moved smoothly with $100M EDC commitments, union electricians, and promises of ~1,000 jobs. Then the room turned into a battlefield over Arrow Linen, a Windsor Terrace laundry site: Community Board 7 had voted 30-6 against, opponents demanded the towers be cut to seven stories with 40% affordability, longtime residents pleaded against 'two luxury hot towers,' while renters and pro-housing groups argued Windsor Terrace has built no new affordable units since
From the room
“there is an R seven D district, much like we are asking, immediately across Concord Avenue. This was zoned, uh approved by the council in twenty twenty one”
— Richard Lobel
“we're going to be doing multiple developments in your district with your community board. We're going to be back here before this committee multiple times.”
— Richard Bass
“We engaged Catholic charities to make a market rate offer based on a seven to nine story zoning to build 100% affordable housing. ARO rejected it”
— Jacob Walsh
“other applicants had actively engaged the community and provided for their own needs instead of just their own self-interests, like Arrow Linen”
— Alex
01
The decisions
7
01LU 0206-2024C 240363 ZMQZoning MapLaid over
White Stone
Took up a commercial-overlay mapping for the Gleason Funeral Home in Whitestone, Queens, spanning three lots on 150th Street and 11th Avenue in Council Member Paladino's district. The overlay would finally bring into conformance a funeral home that has operated on the site since 1913.
The deal
Site
White Stone
Land-use review
CB Queens CB7 Approve With Conditions
PropertiesWhite Stone
Where it standsCB Queens CB7 ✓→Committee→Full Council
A rezoning in the Mount Haven section of the Bronx would clear the way for a mixed-use building with manufacturing, commercial space and roughly 87 apartments. It shifts four parcels plus portions of two others from an M1-2 district to an M1-4/R7D district.
A rezoning would replace the Arrow Linen Company's Windsor Terrace site with roughly 244 apartments, changing the existing R5B district to R7-1 alongside a zoning text amendment. The family-owned business has owned and operated the site for over 40 years, running a non-conforming commercial laundry there for nearly a century.
with 2 related matters · LU 0215-2025 · LU 0216-2025
Paired with the SPARC campus application as items 215 and 216, this rezoning would facilitate a new commercial life-science building, also in Kips Bay.
with 6 related matters · LU 0218-2025 · LU 0219-2025 · LU 0220-2025 · LU 0221-2025 · LU 0223-2025 · LU 0224-2025
EDC pitched redeveloping about 4.75 acres of city-owned land in Kips Bay, replacing Hunter College's aging Brookdale campus with roughly 2 million square feet of academic, healthcare and life-science space. Branded SPARC Kips Bay (the Science Park and Research Campus), it was presented as a first-of-its-kind education, workforce and industry hub built through a New York State and New York City partnership, advanced via a city map application within the broader ULURP package.
E-designation elevates oversight to Mayor's Office of Environmental Remediation (OER); strict soil remediation oversight; possible SSDS or vapor barrier
Questions & answers
Keith Powers: Asks the applicant to explain the difference between the as-of-right use for laboratory space and what is being requested via the special permit.
Keith Powers: Asks whether granting the special permit would preclude housing on the site, and whether additive housing opportunities in the area have been explored.
Procedure
Santos Rodriguez asked for two more minutes; Chair allowed him to finish testimony — Kevin C. Riley
Chair calls Jennifer Rosati to testify on SPARC — Kevin C. Riley
Committee on zoning and franchises hearing called to order — Kevin C. Riley
Public directed to fill out testimony slip with sergeant at arms, include project number and name — S9
+13 more procedural steps
02
The people
Public testimony: 19 in favor · 8 opposed
Practitioners & applicants
Richard Bass · Richard Lobel · Shahana K. Hanif · public commenter (S4, neighborhood landlord) · Scott Newman · Hafina Allen · Eric McClure · Dr. Henry Love · Ralph Gaddo · Julia Harris · +15 more
03
The intelligence
Every parcel, owner, and applicant in this meeting, cross-referenced against Zonable’s NYC ownership, enforcement & legislative graph — the record behind the record.
Sign in for the full graph
Owner portfolios, open OATH/ECB violations, 311 & DOB permits across every parcel discussed, developer track records, and an “ask this meeting” chat. For this meeting: 585 oath/ecb hearings across the 4 sites discussed.
Ask about this meeting
Sign in to ask questions
Chat with AI about this meeting. Free account required.