Subcommittee on Zoning and Franchises · Tuesday, September 17, 2024
The one where Amtrak, FEMA flood maps, and a six-lane highway all crash a 60-unit Hudson-edge rezoning hearing
Contents & search
items
11
approved
5
laid over
5
filed
1
land-use items
11
units
170
affordable
48
CEQR: Other
Try
At this zoning subcommittee, three projects took live testimony before their votes. The marquee fight was 701 West 135th Street (CrossCap Holdings, attorney Neil Weisbarr): a 7-story, ~60-unit mixed-use building rezoning M1-1 to R7-2/C2-4, 15-18 units permanently affordable. CM Abreu backed it, but online speakers hammered the FEMA flood zone, air quality 'adjacent to a six-lane highway', a bulkhead obstructing park views, petroleum in the soil, and Amtrak's objection. Repeat applicant rep Eric Polatnik ('~75 rezonings') walked 2390 McDonald Ave (80 units, ~24 affordable) past the F train. CM
From the room
“change the existing residential RFB and RFD districts with a C one-three commercial overlay to an R six A residential district with a C one-4 overlay”
— Kevin C. Riley
“the owner has worked with the community board to identify practices and protocol to protect neighboring properties and community members.”
— Erik D. Bottcher
“Demolition of more than 20% of a building in this district requires a special permit in order to protect the neighborhood from speculative development pressures.”
— Erik D. Bottcher
“executing an agreement with the neighboring property to repair damages to 341 West 47th Street prior to the city planning commission”
— Erik D. Bottcher
01
The decisions
11
01LU 0138-2024C 230022 ZMQZoning MapApproved
Astoria
with 1 related matter · LU 0139-2024
Approved with modifications as part of the day's first vote, paired with companion items LU 138 and 139.
230355 ZRK (250 86th Street Rezoning submitted by Dr. Helen Kim, pursuant to Section 201 of the New York City Charter, for an amendment of the Zoning Resolution of the City of New York, modifying APPENDIX F for the purpose of establishing a Mandatory Inclusionary Housing area, Borough of Brooklyn, Community District 10, Council District 47.
A West Harlem residential rezoning (R7-2 with a C2-4 overlay) atop an Amtrak right-of-way near Riverside Drive and 12th Avenue, scaled down from the original 2016 14-story R8 plan to 7 stories, 71.5 feet, and 4.6 FAR with a bulk special permit and MIH options 1 and 2; CB9, Amtrak, and residents pushed back over environmental contamination, flooding in flood zones X and AE, and buildability. The project's roots trace to 2016 when the applicant first met with City Planning.
Conditions
development cannot proceed without full review by Amtrak; per Amtrak's letter of authorization
noise attenuation requirements enforced by an (E)-designation
Land-use review
CEQR: Other
CEQR: Other
CEQR: Other
CEQR: Other
CEQR: Other
CB Manhattan Community Board 9
CB Manhattan Community Board 9 Disapprove
Where it standsCB Manhattan Community Board 9 ✓→Committee→Full Council
A special permit to proceed with partial demolition of a vacant four-unit residential building at 343 West 47th Street in the Special Clinton District, after work was stopped for lacking the required demolition approvals; a DOB audit of the July 2019 and October 2020 permits found more than 20% of residential floor area was being removed, which triggered the special-permit requirement (LU 153).
A Gravesend, Brooklyn rezoning from C8 to C4-4L to enable a roughly 80-unit residential mixed-use building beside Gravesend's oldest-in-NYC cemetery; the C4-4L district was created by Brooklyn's City Planning office specifically for sites up against elevated trains.
Neil Weisbarr · Jason Diaz · Annette Robinson · Basia Nikonoro · Lisa Orantia · Shlomo Steve Wygoda
03
The intelligence
Every parcel, owner, and applicant in this meeting, cross-referenced against Zonable’s NYC ownership, enforcement & legislative graph — the record behind the record.
Sign in for the full graph
Owner portfolios, open OATH/ECB violations, 311 & DOB permits across every parcel discussed, developer track records, and an “ask this meeting” chat. For this meeting: 855 oath/ecb hearings across the 5 sites discussed.
Ask about this meeting
Sign in to ask questions
Chat with AI about this meeting. Free account required.